Bryce and Mad Max are both going to be on the All Decade team from other seasons,
but here's some of their dominant 2018 cards!
Lineup: There's *so* much potential in this lineup, especially for flexibility. Trea Turner is a natural leadoff man with his 23 speed and tons of extra base pop... but due to the On Base 8 and the SIX OB 10 guys in the lineup, I've decided to put 19 speed Soto at the top to maximize ABs for the best hitters and let Trea act as an "early leadoff man" in the nine spot. Speaking of, Juan Soto is an absolute beast of a leadoff hitter -- he can do it all, with a lot more power than you expect at leadoff. The All Decade Nationals have the quintessential example of "best player hits second" in 2015 MVP Bryce Harper. Perhaps the frontrunner for NL MVP in the All Decade league, this Bryce basically has Soto's chart.... as an OB 11. Pitchers better fear this guy, but he's backed up by lethal OB 10 Rendon!! Sneaky clean up Daniel Murphy is going to be a lethal hitter -- I love his giant double range and triple on his chart. The lineup doesn't let up, with Howie delivering a very good OB 10 card (and here's hoping for some Grand Slam magic at some point from him in the All Decade league)! Jayson Werth, in a beautiful card from Colby/Matthew, shows that his giant contract wasn't a complete waste from a very good 2013 season. He's an OB 10 that gets on at 4 and has speed, making him a dangerous number 6 hitter! Then you've got the basic OB 8, HR at 16 hitter in the 7 hole with Nationals legend Ryan Zimmerman. At catcher, Washington's lucky to avoid having to punt with Wilson Ramos -- a good +7 arm with 15 double and 18 homer. He won't put up giant numbers, but I think he's going to contribute just fine and keep the lineup rolling.... into Trea Turner, who'll essentially be the leadoff man as soon as the lineup has churned through once!
Rotation: Wowza -- what a collection of aces! I don't think anyone is surprised that their rotation is completely loaded. Of course we're starting with a Cy Young Max Scherzer -- a Tier 2 with a giant K range, no doubles, Control 4.... and he could arguably be the #4 starter as the only non-Control 6. Strasburg's best season came in 2017 with a 2.53 ERA, and he earned a Control 6, no doubles card that can absolutely dominate games. At number three comes the only Tier 1 starter, oddly enough, in Colby/Matt's Doug Fister. Hard to argue if you wanted to put him at #1 with his C6, on at 17 card, but I'm (in violation of my own personal opinions) putting the "no doubles" above tiers (in large part because of star power). Rounding it out is one of my personal favorite pitchers of all-time, native of Auburndale, Wisconsin -- Jordan Zimmerman!!! He's a Tier 2, C6 guy with tons of IP and a solid chart. No pitcher in the rotation is below 550 points and the rotation comes in at a staggering 2320 points!
This is a side tangent from the Showdown talk that I hope y'all find entertaining, but I went to a Nats-Brewers game to see Zimmerman pitch. An entire section from Auburndale was there, and it frankly could've been half the town. Auburndale is a town (maybe a town) of about 700 people in central Wisconsin. It's about twenty minutes from my Grandma's house and my family's hometown of Marshfield, WI and it's.... man, there's absolutely nothing there and it's AMAZING that a major league star came out of this part of Central Wisconsin. What's even crazier, former Green Bay Packer Mark Tauscher is also from Auburndale. Town of 700 -- 2 professional athletes. Needless to say, Zimmerman is an absolute legend to our region and I'm *hyped* to have this beautiful card that Matthew Pennertz made to honor/play with him in the All Decade league!
(main street of Zimmerman's hometown... seriously, how are two pro athletes from here??)
- Yankees 7920 points
- Nationals 7670 points
- Astros 7420 points
- Mariners 6880 points
- Marlins 6750 points
- Tigers 6710 points
Alrighty here we go on the Natty boys! This team probably is better than the Yankees all around, but based on my metrics the Yankees bullpenn is a bit better.
ReplyDeleteLineup:
I am questioning Bryce's OF designation as I believe he was listed as L/R when the card was originally printed!!!! O.o But that card is a STUD with 7.09 expected runs, Rendon's 2019 is at 6.3 and Soto right behind him at 6.18. If you can't use Bryce in CF you need to slide Robles PR card in which severely hinders this lineup at only 3.97 runs. If you let the designation slide then I agree wholeheartedly with this lineup. Comes in ahead of the Yankees by a decent bit too.
Rotation:
I agree on your selection, but I have Strasburg at the top with 5.26 runs, then Fister at 5.33, Scherzer at 5.73 and Zimmerman at 6.15. Wild to think he's from that small of a town (actually called a village not a town according to Wikipedia), I thought where I'm from with a population of 4,000 odd people was tiny!
Bullpen:
I have Doolittle and Clippard as the 1-2 punch with Doolittle's card coming in at a ridiculous 4.17 runs, Clippard at a very good 4.95 and then Storen at 5 flat. Stammen and Grace round out the penn at 5.97 and 6.78 and that is the reason the Yankees 'pen is better :)
Hyped this analysis is back!!! Bryce got re-evaluated and put in CF (partially it'll just be way more fun)... Only question is who Grace is? I would've expected Stammen was the worst reliever by far with Clippard bringing a Tier 1 card!
DeleteMatt Grace from the 2018 set! 2 Control, 18 outs, a walk and a double. Now that I'm looking at it though I think my calculations are off because Papelbon should be above him with a similar chart and 4 control...looking into that
Delete