Friday, November 13, 2026

2016 Showdown Bot Set - Pittsburgh Pirates

As can be said too often, this is not a great Pirates team. It’s far from the worst though, and there is certainly value to be found, not to mention a big hitter or two.

My favorite card on this team is Francisco Cervelli, a 10 On Base catcher with C+8 defense for just 270 points. He’s an early draft pick for sure. Jung Ho Kang is certain to get some attention too. He’s just 8 OB, but his chart has just two outs and lots of power, and he’s a plus defender at 3B. Other infielders provide good defense as well, and Cervelli is not the only budget, high on base card. Gregory Polanco is one of those fun cards with a chart that includes every possible batter outcome.



The pitching isn’t strong either, but there is value here too. Mark Melancon is one of the best closers in the set, with his tier-2, no-doubles card. A solid rookie Pennant Run pitcher will add to the rotation’s potency. Stay tuned!


Craziest Chart: Neftali Feliz – I don’t know that I’ve ever seen a pitcher’s chart with just a 19 walk and 20 homer.


Foils: Starling Marte, Mark Melancon




















Thursday, November 12, 2026

2016 Showdown Bot Set - Cincinnati Reds

The 2016 Reds don’t have a lot of huge stud cards on their team, aside from 11 On Base Joey Votto, but they do have a lot of mid-range value, from several affordable 8 OB cards that get on base, to the best defensive centerfielder in the set, Billy Hamilton. With CF+4 defense and 5 single+ outcomes on his chart, he gets picked up for sure in a draft.

There are other good and affordable defenders, not to mention a few 7 OB power bats. I expect several Reds to be drafted in a 2016 Showdown league, most being hitters. The pitching, as usual in Great American Ballpark, is not so great, though there are a couple good options due to the low relative point value of an 00 style set.



Craziest Chart: Jumbo Diaz. A pitcher with outs from 0-20? If you’re willing to risk 0 Control, you got him.


Foils: Jay Bruce, Joey Votto






















Wednesday, November 11, 2026

2016 Showdown Bot Set - St. Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals have a solid team, as usual. Shortstop Aledmys Diaz is a strong bat (and, hey, infield defense doesn’t matter, right?). The ever-consistent Yadier Molina is a solid all-around catcher. A young Kolten Wong provides plus defense at a couple positions. Perhaps my favorite batter card here value-wise is Matt Carpenter, who plays three infield positions with solid defense and is a 10 OB card with a little extra-base pop for just 400 points.


Seunghwan Oh is perfect for managers who like low-control, high-outs pitchers.


Craziest Charts: 


Jedd Gyorko - Nobody likes 6-out batters charts, but for Gyorko and a couple others, it was the only card version that truly captured his season. To add to the weirdness, it also comes with 5 home runs but no doubles.


Trevor Rosenthal - Control 5, Out through 13, anyone? Hey, at least he doesn’t allow doubles!


Foils: Aledmys Diaz, Carlos Martinez, Yadier Molina