Lineup:
The Phillies have a solid lineup with lots of useful hitters, although the lack of OB 10 hitters can be fatal against high Control pitchers. However, there's plenty of POP in this lineup, especially Rhys Hoskins. His lack of defense makes him an ideal DH draft pick. At the top, Cesar Hernandez is a great, cheap option for a leadoff man -- solid OB, decent speed, and on at 3. Wilson Ramos is my favorite catcher in the set with his combination of high OB, defense, and extra-base power. Carlos Santana and Justin Bour are a stellar 4/5 combo, but won't put any fear into most managers. I actually really like Nick Williams for only 230 points for all the extra-base rolls on his chart, but the OB 7 will scare off a lot of managers. The lineup ends with a trio of OB 6 hitters, which will actually be useful against low control starters thanks to how much power they all have.
As to the bench, Jose Bautista adds a really solid card off the bench. Kingery is AWFUL and Alfaro is similarly terrible, but at least has some OB 6, HR at 17 power.
Rotation: Aaron Nola is a bonafide ace and one of the best starters in the whole set. Not only does he bring a Tier 2 card with a high control, but doesn't surrender doubles -- that's going to make him a very early draft pick, so prioritize him early. Unfortunately, there's a big drop off after Nola. Arrieta is a bland Tier 4, followed up by Tier 5 Pivetta and Velasquez. Overall, not a great rotation but, compared to teams we've seen lately, Nola alone makes it average.
BONUS: Enjoy Matt's epic "throwback jersey" version of Seranthony!
Alright, so that's the Phillies!!! Only two more teams to go (Mariners and Reds) -- stay tuned!
damn Nola is a BEAST. Going to chart up there as a top tier starter, period. You definitely understand why they felt like they had to bolster their lineup after last year and with Harper in there it becomes good enough to get some runs up. Love the throw back jersey card!!
ReplyDeleteWow, thank you guys for putting out so much cards these days.
ReplyDeleteGotta find some time to play more of the 2018 set and Clutch Baseball.
By the way, how do you define the different tiers for pitchers? By salary points?
ReplyDeleteIt's by Control + Outs and it's by far the best way to determine the value of a pitcher vs other pitchers.
DeleteSo a Control 5 pitcher with 1-15 outs is a Tier 3 (David Cone 2000), while a Control 3 pitcher with 1-18 outs is a Tier 2 (Randy Johnson 2000), etc etc etc.
Can hop onto this one and say that the data backs it up. Have realized time and again for both pitchers and batters it plays a huge role in how much value they bring. All about that probability!
DeleteAmazing... only the catchers provide positive defense. OF and IF defense is a 0 LOL
ReplyDeleteHow is Control calculated? I've always wondered this. On-Base is simple enough but I don't get Control.
ReplyDeleteHeads up, Pat Neshek's name is spelled wrong on the card.
ReplyDeleteGood catch, I sent peter the wrong file, I have an updated one too
Delete